What Is Gay Groundhogging?

I read an interesting article about “groundhogging.” There’s a name for everything these days, isn’t there? But I got this one immediately.

The concept and premise comes from the Bill Murray movie, Groundhog Day, where Murray’s character is forced to re-live the same day over and over until he breaks the cycle by using the time to become a better person.

In the world of self-improvement, re-living your Groundhog Day is a popular way of describing what it feels like when you’re stuck living with the results of the same bad habits day after day.

Groundhogging in the dating sense is a fairly recent term, speaking to the tendency to continually cycle in and out of the same dating types, even when history says it’s not a good idea.

A common perception is that every gay man has a type. A type frequently corresponds to things like physical appearance, a fetishized trait, someone’s race or ethnicity, or any combination of these.

Hairy, beefy, skinny, daddy, bear, jock, dominant, submissive, Black, White, Asian, Latino, etc. could be identified as someone’s ideal type.

The problem with relying solely on things that are largely visual and external as a gauge for your ideal partner is that you have no clue what you’re looking for in terms of character, personality, temperament, or other inner qualities.

Groundhogging in Gay Relationship Patterns

So you have a type. What’s the big deal?

Everyone starts somewhere, and when it comes to dating, attraction rules the day. They catch your eye and the pursuit is on.

You see guys together who look like they could be twins. Or one guy who looks old enough to be the other one’s dad. Or the shy intellectual drawn to the social butterfly.

But what’s happening at the unconscious level is a whole other set of types at play. And if I’m honest, the stuff you’d rather not talk about.

• There’s the guy whose life is a wreck paired with the guy who likes a fixer-upper.
• The weak and helpless guy hitched up with the abusive control freak.
• And the elusive non-committal dude chased by the clingy, insecure guy.

Whether the relationships are short-lived or continue for years, at some point they usually end. Often after one or the other partners decides they had enough.

“Never again!” “I’m done!”

Then, after a while (or sometimes immediately, in the case of serial daters), they find someone “better.” They’re just their type.

The cycle starts anew. It’s Groundhog Day all over again.

Why Do You Keep Going for the Same Gay Types?

It takes some self-reflection to figure out why you keep falling for the same guys over and over. Especially when they never seem to work out!

Figuring Out Your Gay Relationship Patterns

It’s easy to identify the overt traits that attract you (physique and demeanor, for example). It’s tricky to get under the hood of the less obvious ones.

Looking back on my dating history, I can tell you I’m not one of those who has a type. I’d say I’m an “all-around” guy who likes all types!

But between me, you, and seat cushion, more often than not my type was either someone who struggled with self-esteem and behaved insecurely, or, someone who was confident but elusive.

The former frustrated me to no end. The latter triggered me with all kinds of insecurity.

They all seemed like variations of my dad, if I’m being honest.

I picked them again and again, too. I spent countless sessions with my therapist agonizing over every negative, disappointing experience.

It really wasn’t until I stopped the endless pursuit of these same kinds of guys that I made any progress toward finding someone right for me.

Owning Your Gay Relationship Patterns

Talk therapy helps a lot. Books do, too.

But one of the best ways to identify and be honest about your groundhogging ways is self-reflection and journaling.

Some good starting points might be:

• Do I look for the same kind of guy because I feel some sort of pressure to conform? For example, maybe he’s the physical ideal everyone aspires to.
• Do I accept anyone who comes my way because the gay dating pool is so small and options are limited?
• Do I dislike myself and feel I don’t deserve any better?
• Does anything about my choices seem familiar or similar to things I might have experienced in childhood?

Breaking Your Gay Relationship Patterns

Breaking the cycle of gay groundhogging is a process. It took me a while to recognize what was going on, let alone trusting myself enough to listen to my gut when I knew someone wasn’t right for me.

Mindfulness and awareness really comes in handy here, because super ingrained patterns have a way of running on auto-pilot without you even knowing.

One technique worked really well: the canary in the coal mine. If my inner “canary” felt like it sensed gas in the mine, I pulled out of that relationship.

Instead of toying with the idea the relationship could work, I took the red flags for what they were, reducing the time I stayed in it from months to weeks to even sometimes days. I got really good at dropping guys sooner than later!

I also shored up my self-confidence. Instead of avoiding guys I felt were out of my league for one reason or another, I engaged with them and asked them out.

I stopped making up stories about why I wasn’t good enough or that I wasn’t their type.

And I made conscious a decision not to invite any and everyone in just because they were interested in me. That’s hard to do when the dating pool feels completely dry!

Building Fulfilling Gay Relationships

Recognizing and breaking gay relationship patterns can be a transformative journey. It starts with self-awareness and a willingness to examine your dating habits critically.

Whether it’s through talk therapy, self-reflection, or journaling, understanding why you’re attracted to certain types can help you break free from the repetitive cycle.

Instead of focusing solely on physical traits or superficial characteristics, delving deeper into what truly matters in a relationship, such as compatibility or shared values, can really pave the way to getting to know someone who doesn’t necessarily fit your usual “type.”

Shoring up your mindfulness and self-confidence makes it easier to recognize red flags and trust your instincts.

By being more selective and intentional about your dating choices, you can also avoid falling into the trap of dating the same type of guy over and over.

Ultimately, breaking from your own groundhogging inclinations isn’t just about finding someone, it’s about creating a healthier, more fulfilling approach to relationships. Doing so, you open the door to genuine connections and the possibility of a lasting, meaningful relationship.

Next time you’re asked, “Who’s your type?” take a breath and reflect on that! What truly makes you happy and fulfilled?

Embrace the adventure of dating the variety of types that are out there, and you might just find that one you’re looking for was outside your comfort zone all along.

---

Disclaimer: The information and perspectives shared in my posts, articles, and videos are based on my personal experiences and reflections. I am not a licensed therapist, counselor, or medical professional, and this content should not be considered a substitute for professional advice. If you are experiencing distress, depression, or mental health challenges, please reach out to a qualified professional who can provide the help you need. For immediate support, contact a mental health provider or, if you are in crisis, please call the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 (available in the U.S.) or your local emergency number.